Cookies

Hand Crafted

brown cookies on round brown bowl

Not Just Cookies…

From the American classics to specialty cookies, Mikkelsen’s Pastry Shop in Naples, Florida can bake just about anything you dream up. Whether you’re looking for creamy peanut butter flavor, chunky chocolate chip, an oatmeal raisin blend or our tasty coconut pecan, we have enough options to keep your taste buds busy! Choose your favorite flavor, mix and match, or trust us to whip up something yummy and unique!

Mikkelsen’s is famous for their exquisite desserts. Whether you’re putting on a commercial event or a special occasion for friends and family, our pastries will be the talk of the party. Word-of-mouth is how we’ve grown to the booming business we are today. However, we haven’t sacrificed our friendly service for bigger numbers. At the end of the day, we don’t consider our job well done unless we’ve done what we can to ensure our customers’ satisfaction.

Tea Cookies

Mikkelsen’s Pastry Shop bakes a variety of cookies that will pair nicely with your favorite tea! Whether you’re a fan of traditional Earl Grey or like to test your palate with fruit teas, we have a cookie to go with it! 

American Cookies

There is arguably, nothing more American than the traditional Chocolate Chip cookie. It’s hard to perfect what’s already so good! Our team bakes fresh, warm cookies from scratch every day. Get your sweet fix for the day with traditional cookies including Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, and Snickerdoodle!

Specialty Cookies

Cookies come in all shapes and flavors! Choose from our not-so-traditional cookies, including Florentines, Rugleach, Madelines, and Biscotti!

cookies with chocolate drizzled on top of them
brown cookies on white textile

Southwest Florida’s Best Homemade Cookies

Satisfy

At Mikkelsen’s Pastry Shop, cookies are more than just treats; they are little bites of happiness crafted with love and passion. Each cookie is a delightful creation, baked to perfection with the finest ingredients, ensuring a warm, gooey center and a crisp edge. Whether you’re indulging in our classic chocolate chip, savoring the nutty richness of peanut butter, or trying our unique specialty selections, every bite is an invitation to experience the joy of homemade goodness. Let your taste buds dance with delight as you explore our diverse cookie offerings, perfect for any occasion or just a sweet moment to yourself.

Not Just Cookies…

COOKIE TYPEPRICE
Tea Cookies
Macaroons (Coconut or Almond) • Florentines
Keylime Sandwich • Chocolate Linzer • Ginger •
Raspberry Doily • Chocolate Dipped Sugar • Rugelach
Piped Butter – (by the pound only)
$12 by the Pound or $1.00 each
Tea Cookies
Biscotti • Macaroons (Coconut or Almond) • Almond
Marzipan • Mexican Wedding Cookies • Biscotti
$13 by the Pound or $1.10 each
Cookie Cakes Quarter Sheet – $32.00
Half Sheet – $54.00
American Cookies
Chocolate Chip • Peanut Butter • Oatmeal Raisin
Coconut Pecan • Coconut Keylime • Molasses Ginger
White Chocolate Cherry • Snickerdoodle
$1.15 to $1.25